The Legal Conservative

Having just read this decision, and the evolution of the evolving standards of decency and proportionality review, in addition to the first ever time that I remember the court completing a social study that was cited  by a party, and using it to justify the holding in the case- all I can say is wow- second time in about 20 years I have been rendered speechless by the tortured logic of a U.S.C.T. decision.

08-7412.pdf application/pdf Object.

This really does deserve a fuller review, so more analysis to follow.

Here it is – weekend reading, the amended complaint filed by Attorney General Bill McCollum in the challenge to the constitutionality of the health care act.  Analysis to follow.   AMENDED COMPLAINT FINAL Date Stamped 051410

Experts Split on State Lawsuits Over Health Care Law – NYTimes.com.

Will have to give the times their due, this is a more reasoned explanation of the key issues in the case then most analysis I have seen by the Times.